Feet of Clay, Terry Pratchett
I talked about this a little
last time, but finally finished it this evening, and of course it just kept on getting better. I'm not sure I'd ever realised how apt the title is. Of course it applies literally in the case of the golems, but also figuratively in the case of Nobby, so that's both sub-plots taken care of, but then Pratchett takes it up a level in the final denouement, revealing that it applies to literally everyone in the city, even the nobles who are convinced that they are the ones plotting to raise Nobby to the crown. And while I mentioned Cheery/Cheri's discomfort with the idea of a werewolf in the Watch, and how Pratchett plays with that by having her discuss it repeatedly with Angua, the actual werewolf, I'd forgotten or not noticed that he was playing a double game by then having Angua unconsciously express her own dislike of other species of undead (Pratchett is fairly unique in considering werewolves undead, though I can see where he's coming from, Angua has survived been fatally shot in the past). And yet again he delivers a plot that would be notably clever even for a dedicated author of locked room mysteries, one where it takes forever for the light to dawn on not just characters, but readers too. And that's without mentioning that he deftly waves the entire plot under our noses in a pair of appallingly clever bilingual puns in pretty much the first chapter. Damn, I'm going to miss having new Discworld books.
Like a Mighty Army, David Weber.
I mentioned this
last time too, but I finally finished all 585 pages yesterday (not to mention the 66 page dramatis personae). My comments from last time stand, in fact even more so. We barely check-in with the chief bad-guys this time, whereas they've had a substantial chunk of the text in previous books, while there is precisely zero development in the something nasty lurking in the Temple crypts sub-plot.
What we do have is the unfolding of the military campaign in Southern Siddarmark in great detail, and to an extent it almost feels sordid because the good guys have so many advantages. Not only do they have real time reconnaissance against a mid-19th Century technology level opponent (though a very limited number of people who can access it), but they have thoroughly compromised the other guys' command and control loop by feeding them false information, and the bad guys (aka the Church) have completely underestimated how many of them there are (while still outnumbering them). The only thing that stops it being utter war-porn is that even when they can bring the bad guys to battle at times and places of their choosing, the good guys as still outnumbered many times over and even the final battle costs their forces engaged something like 50% casualties. As usual Weber does go out of his way to humanise the bad guys as good soldiers following orders, in this case via the Dohlarans and especially the Dohlaran General Sir Rainos Ahlverez*, but also sets an even more substantial portion as incompetents who deserve what's coming to them, here in the shape of the Desnairians, who are convinced in the inevitable triumph of the noble horseman, to the extent of not being able to even feed themselves, and specifically in their general, the Duke of Harless, who doesn't even get the courtesy of dying nobly in battle. The bad guys are also renamed the Army of Shiloh halfway through the book, which will have a specific resonance for American fans who are familiar with the American Civil War, but I'm not familiar enough with the operational details of the ACW to know whether the campaign has any real resonance with the historical Shiloh campaign.
There's also comparatively little naval activity in comparison to earlier books, the Charisians are now so dominant they can even deliberately challenge updated fortresses from their warships (historically the warship has always had major disadvantages in engaging shore batteries). There's one sequence with one of their new ironclads making the crossing to Siddarmark which is basically a storm story, and another with a new class of ironclad line-of-battle ship deliberately making itself a target for a fortress. Weber calls it a broadside ironclad, but broadside ironclads in our history were (semi-)steam-powered, as were the floating batteries that preceded them, while the Charisian
Rottweiler class are sail-only, so I think he's actually come up with something new. And even with that level of advantage I did some lurking on his forums and he's talking about jumping them another 30 years forward to turn of the 20th Century armoured cruisers as the next step (all of which is his background in wargames design showing through, as it did in the Honor Harrington books, and especially the Starfire books, which were outright based on a game system he was at one time the developer for).
On the espionage front, there's more Inquisition brutality, though this time against their own people, and prompting Merlin to
send a message in a particularly brutal manner, while there's another (and particularly nasty) Church-inspired act of terrorism, this time directed at teen-couple Irys and Hektor, which provides a handy excuse for a plot development that means by the end of the book Merlin is no longer the only person on Safehold to remember the Terran Federation. And at the very end of the book Aivah/Nynian throws everyone a complete curveball.
I like these, I really do, but they're a very specific taste, and absolutely not a series you can dive into the middle of.
* Possibly unfairly, it occurs to me that most of the non-Northern European names just happen to be on the side of the bad guys, while the good guys are all Anglo-Germanic or Celts, and for that matter the next book should show the Charisians taking on all one and a half million of the
Asian Horde Imperial Harchongese Army.
I haven't actually read anything else in the sense of starting at page one, but I did skim extensive chunks of both
How Firm a Foundation and
War Maid's Choice to get me back up to speed with Weber's
Safehold and
War God's Own series. Comments from last time cover both fairly adequately.